Metaphysics of correspondence: some approaches to the classical theory of truth

Publication Type:

Language:

Transliteration of original Title: 
Metafizika sootvetstviya: nekotorye podkhody k korrespondentnoi teorii istiny
Author(s): 
Konstantin G. Frolov
Saint Petersburg Electrotechnical University
Issue number: 
No.1 (Vol.55)
Pages: 
83-98
Abstract: 

The article examines main competing conceptions of the correspondence theory of truth. First, the author investigates possible candidates for the role of truth-bearers. Among those he examines following entities: instances of sentences as concrete sequences of symbols (sounds or letters), which should satisfy wide scope of requirements, such as to be grammatical, meaningful, affirmative and so on; abstract propositions, which are expressed by concrete sentences; utterances (either explicit or in lingua mentalis); beliefs of agents as their special mental states. Then he turns to the study of possible candidates for the role of truth-makers, i.e. of those entities to which truth-bearers should correspond to be true. He observes states of affairs, situations, facts and mereological sums of individuals. Then he shows that a notion of correspondence is a functional relationship of interpretation of linguistic expressions, where certain fragment of reality is taken as a model, i.e. as a finite set of elements on which some functions and relations can be operationally defined. He shows how in some simple cases such interpretation function can be built in operationalist’s manner. After that, he considers some natural objections to this approach, which point that he has no direct cognitive access to the actual world, so it is not possible to take its fragments as a model for any theory. Such objections lead us to the coherentist’s approach, but he shows that the question about origin and status of so-called “specified set” implicitly either leads to infinite regress or requires certain correspondence on some level of investigation and reasoning. Finally, the authore presents some reflections on the meaning of correspondence approach for scientific realism and all other versions of realistic philosophy and metaphysics.

 

Keywords: 
correspondence theory of truth, coherence theory of truth, scientific realism, operationalism, interpretation
References: 

Ankin, D. V. “Ob"ektivnost' istiny i poznaniya v kontekste relyatsionnosti znacheniya i sushchestvovaniya” [Objectivity of truth and knowledge in the context of relational character of concepts and existence], Episteme, 2007, no.5, pp. 133-140. (In Russian)

Armstrong, D. M. A Combinatorial Theory of Possibility. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1989. 158p.

Armstrong, D. M. Truth and Truthmakers. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2004. 172p.

Bridgman, P.W. The Logic of Modern Physics. New York: Macmillan, 1927. 242p.

Cherniak, A. “Belief Content and Belief State”, Epistemology & Philosophy of Science, Vol. 45, no.3, 2015, pp. 98-117.

Chudinov, E. M. Priroda nauchnoi istiny [The nature of scientific truth]. Moscow: Political Literature Publ., 1977. 312 p. (In Russian)

Curry, H.B. Formalist Philosophy of Mathematics. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publishing Company, 1951. 75 p.

David, M. “Truth-making and Correspondence”, in: E. J. Lowe and A. Rami (eds.).Truth and Truth-making.. Stocksfield: Acumen Press, 2009, pp. 137-157.

James W. Pragmatism: A New Name for some Old Ways of Thinking. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1975. 142 p.

Kirkham, R.L. Theories of Truth. Cambridge MA: MIT Press, 1992. 401 p.

Kusliy, P.S. “Ponyatie istiny v analiticheskoi filosofii” [The concept of truth in analytic philosophy]. In: A.L. Nikiforov (ed.). Ponyatie istiny v sotsiogumanitarnom znanii [The concept of truth in socio-humanitarian knowledge]. Moscow: IPhRas Publ., 2008, pp. 55-77. (In Russian)

Lamberov, L.D. “Stat'i iz SEP (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Poyasneniya k perevod” [Entries from SEP (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Notes to translation], Episteme, 2007, no.5, pp. 133-140. (In Russian)

Lamberov, L.D. “Deflyatsionnye teorii istiny: problema obobshchennogo opredeleniya” [Deflationary theory of truth: the problem of generalized definition], in: Sibirskii filosofskii zhurnal, 2011, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 13-19. (In Russian)

Lebedev, M.V. (ed.) Analiticheskaya filosofiya [Analytical Philosophy]. Moscow: RUDN Publ., 2006. 624 p. (In Russian)

Lowe, E.J. An Essentialist Approach to Truth-making. In: Truth and Truth-making. Ed. by E. J. Lowe and A. Rami. Stocksfield: Acumen Press, 2009, pp. 201-216.

Makeeva, L.B. Yazyk, ontologiya i realism [Language, Ontology and Realism]. Moscow: HSE Publ., 2011. 311 p. (In Russian)

Nikifirov, A.L. “O filosofskom znachenii semanticheskogo ponyatiya istiny” [On philosophical meaning of semantic concept of truth], Filosofskie nauki, no.2, 1969, pp. 34-52. (In Russian)

Nikiforov, A.L. Filosofiya nauki: istoriya i metodologiya [Philosophy of Science: History and Methodology]. Moscow: DIK, 1998. 280 p. (In Russian)

Nikiforov, A.L. (ed.) Ponyatie istiny v sotsiogumanitarnom znanii [The concept of truth in socio-humanitarian knowledge]. Moscow: IphRas Publ., 2008. 212 p. (In Russian)

Strawson, P.F. “Truth”, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 1950, vol. 24,  pp. 111–56.

DOI: 
10.5840/eps201855110
Full Text: