Cognitive linguistics and philosophy of mind: an explanatory gap in the ontology of linguistic sign

Publication Type:


Transliteration of original Title: 
Kognitivnaya lingvistika i filosofiya soznaniya: ob"yasnitel'nyy razryv v ontologii yazykovogo znaka
Pavel Baryshnikov
Pyatigorsk State University
Issue number: 
No.4 (Vol.50)

This paper is aimed to analyze some grounds bridging the explanatory gap in philosophy of mind and linguistic sign theory. It’s noted that the etymological ties between the notions of “consciousness”, “cognition”, “sign” are emphasized in the works on cognitive linguistics. This connection rises from the understanding of the symbolic nature of consciousness and the sign of semiosis as the key cognitive processes. On the one hand, it is impossible to realize the communication procedures, knowledge, understanding, decision-making, orientation and even navigation without the process of signification. On the other hand, the human mind has its unique ability to produce the meaning apart from the “signal markings” available to other living beings. The ontology of this ability should be considered as a part of the complex problem of consciousness which includes the mind-body problem, the free will problem, image
memory, narrative worlds, introspection, etc. In this paper, special attention is paid to the ontological and epistemological aspects of linguistic sign within the context of the bio-semiotic approach. The author argues that the linguistic nature of consciousness is inseparably connected with the ontological properties of consciousness. The author makes an attempt to prove the link between the mind-body problem and the problem of the explanatory gap in the ontology of linguistic sign. The analysis is focused on the following question: Is it possible that the rank of random names could cause the behavior of referential semantics, philosophy of language, cognitive turn, cognitive and biological model of language, ontology of language sign, intentionalitythe organism in changing environment?

referential semantics, philosophy of language, cognitive turn, cognitive and biological model of language, ontology of linguistic sign, intentionality

Alefirenko N. F. Lingvokognitivnaja sinergetika: istoki, principy, sushhnost' [Linguistic and cognitive synergy: origins, principles, nature]. In: Studia linguistica cognitiva. Irkutsk.: Izd-vo BSU, 2009, pp. 228–256. (In Russian)

Baryshnikov P. N. Zavarzina, S. Vychislitel'nye formy figurativnoj semantiki: ot analogii k inferencii [Computational forms of the figurative semantics: from analogy to inference]. In: Vestnik Vologodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, 2016, no.1, pp. 25–32. (In Russian)

Boldyrev N. N. Koncept i znachenie slova [Concept and word meaning]. In: N. N. Boldyrev (ed.). Metodologicheskie problemy kognitivnoj lingvistiki: [Methodological problems of cognitive linguistics: interuniversity proceedings]. Voronezh. Izd-vo VS, 2001, pp. 25-36. (In Russian)

Zalevskaja A. A. Problem of knowledge in different perspecrives [Problema znanija v razlichnyh rakursah]. In: A.V.Kravchenko (ed.) Studia linguistica cognitiva. Irkutsk.: Izd-vo BSU, 2009,  pp.14-65. (In Russian)

Cowley S.J. Ponjatie raspredelennogo jazyka i ego znachenie dlja voleiz’javlenija [The concept of distributed language and its importance for the expression of the will]. In: A.V.Kravchenko (ed.) Studia linguistica cognitiva. Irkutsk.: Izd-vo BSU, 2009,  pp.192-228. (In Russian)

Kravchenko A. Znak, znachenie, znanie. Ocherk kognitivnoj filosofii jazyka. [Sign, meaning knowledge. Essay on cognitive philosophy of language]. Irkutsk: Izdanie OGUP "Irkutskaja oblastnaja tipografija №1", 2001, 261 p. (In Russian)

Kuznetsov A. Kognitivnye issledovanija i problema mental'noj kauzal'nosti. [Cognitive research and the problem of mental causation].  In: Voprosy filosofii,  2014, no.3, pp. 133–143. (In Russian)

Lakoff G. Myshlenie v zerkale klassifikatorov [Thinking in the mirror of classifiers]. In: V.V. Petrov, V.I. Gerasimov (eds.) Novoe v zarubezhnoj lingvistike. Kognitivnye aspekty jazyka. [New in foreign linguistics. Cognitive aspects of language]. Moscow: Progress, 1988, pp.12-52. (In Russian)

Maturana U. Biologija poznanija [Biology of cognition]. In: V.V.Petrov (ed.) Jazyk i intellekt [Language and intelligence]. Moscow: Izdatel'skaja gruppa "Progress", 1995, pp. 95-143. (In Russian)

Nagumanova S.F. Materializm i soznanie: analiz diskussii o prirode soznanija v sovremennoj analiticheskoj filosofii. [Materialism and consciousness: an analysis of the debate about the nature of consciousness in contemporary analytic philosophy]. Kazan.: Kazanskij un-t, 2011. 222 p. (In Russian)

Paviljonis R.I. Problema smysla: sovremennyj logiko-filosofskij analiz jazyka. [The problem of meaning: the modern logical-philosophical analysis of language]. Moscow: Mysl', 1983. 286 p. (In Russian)

Savenkov A. Malen'kij issledovatel'. Razvitie poznavatel'nyh sposobnostej. 5-7 let. [Little Explorer. The development of cognitive abilities. 5-7 years]. Yaroslavl.: Akademija razvitija, 2004. 32 p. (In Russian)

Hintikka J. Logiko-jepistemologicheskie issledovanija. [Logical and epistemological study]. Moscow: Progress 1980. 446 p. (In Russian)

Baryshnikov P. N. Animal communication systems and “the Rubicon” in the theories of the origin of language.  In: Bulletin of Peoples’ Friendship University, 2016,  no.1, pp. 81–90.

Bickerton D. Language & species. Chicago. University of Chicago Press, 1992. 297 p.

Byrne A. Intentionalism Defended. In: The Philosophical Review, 2001, Vol.110,  no.2, pp. 199-240.

Cárdenas M. L. Letelier J.-C. Gutierrez C. Cornish-Bowden A. Soto-Andrade J. Closure to efficient causation, computability and artificial life. In: Journal of Theoretical Biology, 2010, Vol.263, no.1, pp. 79–92.

Fodor J. A. The language of thought. NY: Thomas Y. Crowell Company. 1975. 215 p.

Fodor J. A. Concepts. Oxford, New York: Clarendon Press; Oxford University Press, 1998. 174 p.

Jackendoff R. Semantics and cognition. London: The MIT Press, 1983. 283 p.

Jackendoff R. Languages of the mind. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1995. 200 p.

Moreno A. Mereloy J.J. Etxeberria A. Perception, Adaptation and Learning. In: B. McMullin; N. Murphy (eds.). Autopoiesis and Perception. Proceedings of the Workshop on Autopoiesis and Perception. Dublin City University: Dublin, 1992. [, accessed 15.08.2016]

Rehder B. A causal-model theory of conceptual representation and categorization. In: Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 2003, Vol. 29, no. 6, pp. 1141–1159.

Rosen R. Life itself. New York: Columbia University Press, 1991. 285 p.

Schneider S. The language of thought. Cambridge, Mass.:MIT Press, 2011. 259 p.

Tye M. Consciousness, color, and content. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 2000. 98 p.


Full Text: