Publication Type:


Transliteration of original Title: 
Fizika i ekonomika: o prinzpakh sokhraneniya v naucno-issledovatel’skikh programmakh
Alexander Pigalev
Volgograd State University
Issue number: 
No. 3 (Vol. 45)

The purpose of the paper is to retrace methodological and epistemological analogies between physics and economics on the basis of the concept of scientific research program that was proposed by I. Lakatos. It is emphasized that these analogies are expressed first of all in a striking resemblance of the notion of energy in physics to the notion of value in economics. The scrutiny of conservation principles points out their generality that not only covers physics and economics, but also presupposes the peculiar metaphysical foundations as the most persistent component of the “hard core” of scientific research programs in question. It is demonstrated that conservation principles rely on the ontology of a closed system which in its germinal form dates back to the mythological worldview and subsequently modeled nature in physics for a long time and became the basis of the concept of an equivalent exchange in economics as well. The notion of motion is regarded as interlink between the foundations of physics and economics, since both motion and economic exchange are displacement, change and permanence at the same time. The metaphysical background of the conceptualization of substance, thing and motion is examined in the context of the imperative of the identification of nonidentical entities. It is observed that the standard strategy of saving the very idea of conservation at detection of conservation principles violation is system expansion by introducing new hypothetic objects and parameters provided the system still remains a closed one. This practice structurally coincides with saving the “hard core” of the scientific research program with the help of its “protective belt”. The problems of the research strategy under study are discussed in a nutshell taking into account the theoretical consequences of the ontology of the open system.

physics, economics, scientific research program, conservation principles, metaphysics, substance, closed system, open system, energy, value

Akhutin A.V. Istoriya printsipov fizicheskogo eksperimenta (ot antichnosti do XVII veka (The History of the Principles of the Physical Experiment from Antiquity to the XVIIth Century). Moscow, 1976.

Arena R., Dow S., Klaes M. (eds.). Open Economics: Economics in Relation to Other Disciplines. London; New York., 2009. (Routledge Studies in the History of Economics).

Barbour J.B. The Discovery of Dynamics: A Study from a Machian Point of View of the Discovery and the Structure of Dynamical Theories. Oxford, UK, etc., 2001.

Berkson W. Fields of Force. New York, 1974.

Blaug M. Economic Theory in Retrospect. 4th ed. Cambridge, UK, etc., 1990. P. 294-327.

Brach J.-P., Hanegraaff  W.J. Correspondences. Dictionary of Gnosis and Western Esotericism; Hanegraaff  W.J. e.a. (eds.). Leiden; Boston, 2006. P. 275-279.

Capecchi D. History of Virtual Work Laws: A History of Mechanics Prospective. Milan, 2012.

Caravale G. (ed.). Equilibrium and Economic Theory; London; New York, 1997. (Routledge Studies in the History of Economics).   

Chen J. The Physical Foundations of Economics: An Analytical Thermodynamic Theory. Singapore etc., 2005.

Creedy J., Martin V.L. (eds.). Chaos and Non-Linear Models in Economics. Theory and Application. Hants, UK, 1996.  

Daal J, van, Jolink A. The Equilibrium Economics of Léon Walras. London; New York, 1993. 

De Marchi N. (ed.). Nonnatural  Social Science: Reflections on the Project of More Heat Than Light. Durham, NC, 1993.

Gabbey A. New Doctrines of Motion. The Cambridge History of Seventeenth-Century Philosophy. V. 1; D. Garber, M. Ayers (eds.). Cambridge, UK, etc., 1998. Pp. 649-679.  

Gaukroger S. The Emergence of a Scientific Culture: Science and the Shaping of Modernity, 1210-1685. Oxford, UK, etc., 2006.

Grigor’yan A.T. Mekhanika ot antichnosti do nashikh dney (The Mechanics from Antiquity to the Present Day). 2-ye izd., pererab. i dop. Moscow, 1974.

Harman P.M. Energy, Force, and Matter: The Conceptual Development of Nineteenth-Century Physics. Cambridge, UK, etc., 1982.  

Hesse M. Forces and Fields. London, 1962.

Kosmann-Schwarzbach Y. The Noether Theorems: Invariance and Conservation Laws in the Twentieth Century. New York, etc., 2011.  

Lakatos I. Falsifikatsiya i metodologiya naucno-issledovatel’skikh programm (Lakatos I. Falsification and the Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes). Lakatos I. Izbrannye proizvedeniya po filosofii i metodologii nauki. (Lakatos I. Selected Writings on the Philosophy and Methodology of Science). Per. s angl. I.N. Veselovskogo. A.L. Nikiforova, V.N. Porusa. Moscow, 2008.

Leeming D.A. Creation Myths of the World: An Encyclopedia. 2nd ed. Santa Barbara, CA; Denver, CO; Oxford, UK, 2010.

Meyerson E. Tozhdestvennost’ i deistvitelnost’: Opyt teorii yestestvoznaniya kak vvedeniye v metafiziku (Meyerson E. Identity and reality: An Essay on the Theory of Natural Science as the Introduction to Metaphysics). Per. pod. obsch. red. [i s predisl.]D.M. Koigena. Saint-Petersburg, 1912.   

Mirowski P. (ed.). Natural Images of Economic Thought: “Markets Read in Tooth and Claw”. Cambridge, UK, etc., 1994.

Mirowski P. Machine Dreams: Economics Becomes a Cyborg Science. Cambridge, UK, etc., 2002.

Mirowski P. More Heat Than Light: Economics as Social Physics, Physics as Nature’s Economics. Cambridge, UK, etc., 1991.

Newton R.G. From Clockwork to Crapshoot: A History of Physics. Cambridge, MA; London, 2007.

Osler M.J. Divine Will and the Mechanical Philosophy: Gassendi and Descartes on Contingency and Necessity in the Created World. Cambridge, UK, etc., 2004.

Ovchinnikov N.F. Printsipy sokhraneniya: Zakony, summetriya, struktura. (The Conservation Principles: The Laws, the Symmetry, and the Structure). 2-ye izd., ispr.. Moscow, 2009.

Rizvi S.A.T. Philip Mirowski as a Historian of Economic Thought. Historians of Economics and Economic Thought: The Construction of Disciplinary Memory; S.G. Medema, W.J. Samuels (eds.). London; New York, 2001. Pp. 209-222. 

Sarnowsky J. Concepts of Impetus and the History of Mechanics. Mechanics and Natural Philosophy before the Scientific Revolution; W.R. Lard, S. Roux (eds.).   Dordrecht, 2008. (Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science. V. 254). Pp. 121-145.

Sohn-Rethel A. Geistige und körperliche Arbeit: Zur Epstemologie der abendländischen Geschichte. Rev. und erg. Neuauflage. Weinheim, 1989.

Sohn-Rethel A. Warenform und Denkform: Aufsätze. Frankfurt am Main; Wien, 1971.  

Sorabji R. Matter, Space and Motion: Theories in Antiquity and Their Sequel. London, 1988.

Wolff M. Geschichte der Impetustheorie: Untersuchungen zum Ursprung der klassichen Mechanik. Frankfurt am Main, 1978.      

Yourgrau W., Mandelstam S. Variational Principles in Dynamics and Quantum Theory. 2nd. ed. New York; Toronto; London, 1960.

Full Text: