Publication Type:


Transliteration of original Title: 
Sociologija i jepistemologija: obmen kognitivnym opytom
Lyudmila Mikeshina
Moscow Pedagogical State University
Issue number: 
No. 1 (Vol. 43)

The paper examines modern sociology the experience of which enriches social epistemology and philosophy of science. The problem of a universal, general theory is very hard do deal with, though it had emerged as early as in the epoch of Enlightenment. The paper discusses whether a general theory is possible and a methodological role played in its creation by “middle range theories”, that is the approach proposed by American sociologist R. Merton. The methodological structure of Marxist theory, traditionally seen as “the general theory”, is under critical scrutiny. Another aspect of sociological methodology development is G. Ritzer’s ideas of “an integrated sociological paradigm” and also of “a multiply paradigm science”. This approach is used to analyze “a degree of generality” of sociological theories. J.R. Searle’s interpretation of the nature of facts in social sciences, where facts may get an objective status because of an agreement between members of society, is also discussed. On the whole, the paper comes to the conclusion that philosophical and methodological problems in the cognitive experience of modern sociology are diverse and important.

sociology, general theory, middle range theories, multiply paradigm science, fact, R. Merton, G. Ritzer, J. Searle, epistemology

Bourdieu P. Objectivate the subject of objectivation (Ob’ektivirovat' ob’ektivirujuschhego sub’ekta). Bourdieu P. Nachala (Elements). Moscow, 1994.

Gessen B.M. Social'no-jekonomicheskie korni mehaniki N'jutona (Social-economic roots of Newton’s mechanics). Moscow - Leningrad, 1933.

Durkheim E. Sociologija. Ee predmet, metod, prednaznachenie (The Rules of Sociological Method). Moscow, 2006

Kravchenko S.A. Sociologija. Paradigmy cherez prizmu sociologicheskogo voobrazhenija (Sociology. Paradigms through the prism of sociological imagination). Moscow, 2004.

Merton R. Social'naja teorija i social'naja struktura (Merton R. Social theory and social structure). Moscow, 2006.

Mirskaja  E.Ja. Jetos nauki: ideal'nye reguljativy i povsednevnye realii. Jetos nauki (The ethos of science: the ideal regulations and everyday realities). Moscow, 2008.

Mills Ch.R. Sociologicheskoe voobrazhenie (Mills Ch.R. The sociological imagination). M., 2001.

Motroshilova N.V. Otechestvennaja filosofija 50-80-h godov XX veka i zapadnaja mysl' (Russian philosophy in the 50’s-80’s of the XXth century and the Western Thougt). M., 2012.

Porus V.N. A Dispute about Scientific Rationality (Spor o nauchnoj racional'nosti). Filosofija nauki. No. 3. Moscow, 1997.

Ritcer  Dzh. Sovremennye sociologicheskie teorii. Prilozhenie. (Ritzer G. Contemporary Sociological Theory). Saint Petersburg, 2002.

Ivanov D.V. (ed.) Sociologija. Uchebnik  (Sociology. A textbook). Moscow, 2005.

Shtompka P. Theoretical Sociology and the Social Imagination (Teoreticheskaja sociologija i sociologicheskoe voobrazhenie). Sociologicheskij zhurnal, 2001, No 1.

Jejnshtejn A.. Rassuzhdenija ob osnovah teoreticheskoj fiziki. Sobr. nauch.  Trudov. V 4 t. T. IV. M.,1967.

Jadov V.A. Sociologicheskoe issledovanie. Metodologija, programma, metody (A sociological investigation. Methodology, program, methods). M., 1972 .

Full Text: