ERNST MALLY: FROM MEINONG TO ZALTA

Publication Type:

Language:

Transliteration of original Title: 
Jernst Malli: ot Majnonga k Zalte
Author(s): 
Vladimir Seliverstov
National Research University Higher School of Economics
Issue number: 
No. 4 (Vol. 42)
Pages: 
202-208
Abstract: 

This article considers the problem of analysis of Ernst Mally’s theory. The problem mainly lies in the fact that this theory is usually considered in connection with other theories. For example, it can be considered as the development of Alexius Meinong’s theory of objects. Meinong was Mally’s teacher and his ideas have formed the basis of the contemporary study of nonexistent objects, the basis of the theories of Terens Parsons, Richard Routley etc. But he was often criticized for the fact that he claimed as they said  that from his point of view all things exist in one form or another, that the golden mountain or round square exist just like the real mountains, but in some weak or low-grade way. Mally understood problems of Meinong’s theory and tried to suggest possible solutions to these problems. So that in fact we can say that he has created an alternative theory of objects.

Mally’s theory in turn has also influenced the development of Edward Zalta’s theory of abstract objects. In this regard, we can also consider Mally’s theory as a first version of Zalta’s theory. But at the same we want to understand the relations between the theories of Meinong and Mally, Mally and Zalta. Was Mally really so close to introduce a distinction of two types of predication - exemplification and encoding (which was introduced later Zalta), or not? To answer this question, we should consider the Mally’s theory itself.

Keywords: 
theory of objects, Mally, Meinong, Zalta, predication
References: 

Findlay J.N. Meinong’s theory of Objects and Values, 2nd ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1963.

Jacquette D. Mally’s heresy and the logic of Meinong’s object theory // History and Philosophy of Logic, № 10, 1989. P. 1–14.

Linsky B. Ernst Mally’s Anticipation of Encoding // Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy. 2014. № 5. P. 1-14.

Mally E. Briefe Ernst Mallys an Hans Pichler vom 5. Jänner 1934 und vom 6. Jänner 1934 // Mally's unpublished work in the Library Archives of the University of Graz, 1934.

Mally E. Gegenstandstheoretische Grundlagen der Logik und Logistik. Leipzig: Verlag von Johann Ambrosius Barth1912.

Mally E. Groβes Logikfragment // Mally E. Logische Schriften / Wolf and Weingartner. Dordrecht: Reidel, 1971. S. 33–174.

Meinong A. O teorii predmetov – Epistemology & Philosophy of Science, 2011, no.1, pp. 202-230.

Meinong A. Samoizlozhenie. Moscow, 2003.

Meinong A. Über Möglichkeit und Wahrscheinlichkeit. Beiträge zur Gegenstandstheorie und Erkenntnistheorie. Leipzig: J. A. Barth, 1915.

Simons P. «Objects, objectives, dignitatives and desideratives: Meinong on the objects of cognition and affect». Conference «Austrian thought at the turn of the 20th century». The University of Texas at Arlington. November 1-3, 2012.

Zalta E. Mally’s Determinates and Husserl’s Noemata // Ernst Mally—Versuch einer Neubewertung, A. Hieke (ed.), St. Augustin: Academia-Verlag, 1998. P. 1-16.

Zalta E. On Mally's Alleged Heresy: A Reply // History and Philosophy of Logic, №13, 1992. P. 59-68.

Zalta E. The Theory of Abstract Objects, 2004 http://mally.stanford.edu/theory.html.