Publication Type:


Transliteration of original Title: 
K kritike reprezentatsionalizma
Konstantin Frolov
Saint Petersburg State University
Issue number: 
No. 2 (Vol. 36)

The article deals with the basic ideas and approaches to the problem of perception and consciousness, which are known as representationalism. The author describes the specifics of higher-order theories of perception of W. Lycan and higher-order thought theory of D. Rosenthal. Also he discusses some features of a non-reductive version of representationalism in connection with arguments of D. Chalmers, who prefers Frege’s interpretation of content of experience to Russell’s version. Finally, the author addresses several critical arguments which concern the difficulties met by representationalism in cases when it becomes necessary to take into consideration cultural, historical and semantic context of various events and phenomena in the framework of human perception.

representation, intentionality, qualia, explanandum, contextual dependence

Berkli Dzh. "Tri razgovora mezhdu Gilasom i Filonusom” (Berkeley G. “Three Dialogs between Hylas and Philonous”).  Berkeley G. Essays. M., Mysl'. 2000.

Chalmers D. The Conscious Mind: In Search of a Fundamental Theory. Oxford University Press. 1996. P.21.

Chalmers D. The Representational Character of Experience.  The Future for Philosophy. Oxford University Press. 2004.

Dennet D. Consciousness explained. N. Y. 1991.

Dretske F. Naturalizing the Mind. MIT Press. 1995.

Il'enkov E.V. Problem of the ideal. The first paper (Problema ideal'nogo. Stat'ya pervaya).  Voprosy filosofii – Problems of philosophy. 1979. №6

Il'enkov E.V. Problem of the ideal. The second paper.  Voprosy filosofii – Problems of philosophy. 1979. №7.

Lycan W. A simple argument for a higher-order representation theory of consciousness.  Analysis. 2001. №61 (1).

Millikan R. Language, Thought and Other Biological Objects. MIT Press. 1987.

Nagumanova S.F. Materializm i soznanie. Kazan'. 2011.

Petrov M.K. Yazyk. Znak. Kul'tura (Language, Sign, Culture). M., Nauka. 1991.

Rayl G. Ponyatie soznaniya (Ryle G. The concept of mind).  M., 1999.

Rosen S. The yoga of kirtana. New York. Folk Books. 2008.

Rosenthal D. Varieties of higher-order theory.  Higher-Order Theories of Consciousness. Ed. Rocco J. Gennaro. Philadelphia. 2004.

Shpet G.G. “Zametki” (“Notes”).  Dom Burganova. Prostranstvo kul'tury (Burganov House. Cultural space). 2009. №2. S. 191-208.

Tye M. Consciousness, Color and Content. MIT Press. 2000.

Vygotskiy L.S. “Istoriya razvitiya vysshikh psikhicheskikh funktsiy” (“History of development of the higher cognitive functions).  Vygotskiy L.S.  Psikhologi  (Psychologists). M., EKSMO-Press. 2000. S. 512-745.

Full Text: