Publication Type:


Transliteration of original Title: 
Kriteriy, znanie, istina
Alexei Gaginski
Department of Philosophy, Institute of Scientific Information for Social Sciences, Russian Academy of Sciences
Issue number: 
No. 3 (Vol. 37)

The article deals with analysis of the key concepts of epistemology as criterion, knowledge and truth. The author aims to make a distinction between mentioned terms, which would help to solve some difficulties in understanding what the truth is, and shed light on the nature of knowledge. We show that the correspondence theory replaces the truth by many criteria that are necessary for the process of knowledge, but are unable to give an accurate idea of truth itself. Furthermore this theory leads to the contamination of the concepts of truth and knowledge, which in turn brings insoluble problems to the disclosing of their meanings.

truth, knowledge, criterion, guess, Gettier, being, thinking

Antonovskiy A.Yu. “On the difference between truth and knowledge (or On where sociality is rooted in knowledge)” (“O razlichii istiny i znaniya (ili o tom, gde v znanii korenitsya sotsial'nost')”). Nikiforov A.L (ed.) Ponyatie istiny v sotsiogumanitarnom poznanii. Moscow, 2008.

Aristoteles. Metaphysica 1011b. Ross W.D. (ed.) Aristotle’s metaphysics. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1970. Vol. 1.

Chudinov E.M. Priroda nauchnoy istiny. Moscow, 1977.

Diogen Laertskiy. O zhizni, ucheniyakh i izrecheniyakh znamenitykh filosofov. Moscow, 1979.

Filatov V.P. Discussing the article “Knowledge” (Obsuzhdaem stat'yu «Znanie»). Epistemology and philosophy of science - Epistemologiya i filosofiya nauki. 2004. № 1.

Frankfort G., Frankfort G.A., Uilson Dzh., Yakobsen T. “On the threshold of philosophy” (“V preddverii filosofii’). Dukhovnye iskaniya drevnego cheloveka (Spiritual searching of the ancient man). Moscow, 1984.

Gettier E. Is Justified True Belief Knowledge? Analysis. 1963. Vol. 23, no. 6.

Gusev S.S. “Justification” (“Obosnovanie”). Entsiklopediya epistemologii i filosofii nauki (Encyclopedia of epistemology and philosophy of science). Moscow, 2009.

Kasavin I.T. “Truth” (“Istina”). Entsiklopediya epistemologii i filosofii nauki (Encyclopedia of epistemology and philosophy of science). Moscow, 2009.

Lukasevich Ya. “On determinism” (“O determinizme”). Filosofiya i logika L'vovsko-Varshavskoy shkoly (The philosophy of Lviv-Warsaw school). Moscow, 1999. Pp.179-198.

Merkulov I.P. “Is there truth from the point of view of philosophy of evolutionism” (“Sushchestvuet li istina s tochki zreniya filosofii evolyutsionizma?”) Gorelov A.A., Novoselov M.M. Mnogomernost' istiny (Multidimensionality of truth). Moscow, 2008.

Nikiforov A.L. “The concept of truth in theory of cognition” (“Ponyatie istiny v teorii poznaniya”). Nikiforov A.L. (ed.). Ponyatie istiny v sotsiogumanitarnom poznanii (The concept of truth in socio-humanitarian cognition). Moscow, 2008.

Nikiforov A.L. “The correspondence theory of truth” (“Korrespondentnaya teoriya istiny”). Entsiklopediya epistemologii i filosofii nauki. Moscow, 2009, pp. 392-393.

Nikiforov A.L. Analysis of the problem of knowledge: approaches and problems (Analiz ponyatiya znaniya: podkhody i problemy). Epistemology and Philosophy of Science - Epistemologiya i filosofiya nauki. 2009, no. 3. Pp. 61-73.

Ol'khovikov G.K. Knowledge as true, justified belief: how to neutralize counterexamples (Znanie kak istinnoe i obosnovannoe mnenie: kak obezvredit' kontrprimery). Logos. 2009, no. 2 (70). Pp. 44-53.

Plato. Cratylus. 385b. Burnet J. Platonis opera. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1967. Vol. 1.

Platon. Sobranie sochineniy: V 4 t. (Plato. A collection of works in 4 vols.). Moscow, 1993. Vol. 2.

Russell B. William James’s Conception of Truth. Russell B. Philosophical Essays. N.Y., 1996.

Sextus Empiricus. Adversus mathematicos VII. 168-169. Mutschmann H. (ed.) Sexti Empirici opera. Leipzig, 1914. Vol. 2.

Striker G. Κριτήριον τῆς ἀληθείας. Striker G. Essays on Hellenistic Epistemology and Ethics. Cambridge; N.Y., 1996.

Tarski A. “The semantic theory of truth and the foundation of semantics” (“Semanticheskaya teoriya istiny i osnovaniya semantiki”). Analiticheskaya filosofiya: Stanovlenie i razvitie (antologiya) (Analytic philosophy: establishment and development. An anthology). Moscow, 1998, pp. 90-129.

Full Text: