Publication Type:


Transliteration of original Title: 
Fundamental'nye i prikladnye issledovaniya, a ne fundamental'nye i prikladnye nauki
Vitaly Gorokhov
Department of Interdisciplinary Problems in the Advancement of Science and Technology, Institute of Philosophy, Russian Academy of Sciences
Issue number: 
No. 2 (Vol. 40)

The article starts the panel discussion with a statement that the traditional division of sciences in fundamental and applied is wrong and misleading. According to the proposed argument, this division results in qualifying technical sciences as fully applied disciplines which is far from being correct. Technical sciences, just like natural sciences, are claimed to contain technical theories. And because a technically prepared experiment plays such an important role in natural science, it is argued that the aforementioned division should concern fundamental and applied research that can take place in natural sciences as well as in technical sciences, the humanities and social disciplines. This division is argued to gain importance when applied research receives priviliged financing. The author brings illustrations of the damage experienced by specialized science in contemporary Russia as justification for his thesis.


Ahmed H. Nanostructure Fabrication. Proceedings of the IEEE. 1991. Vol. 79. No. 8. P. 1140.

Galiley, Galileo. Mekhanika (Mechanics). Izbrannye trudy v 2-kh t. (Selected works in 2 vols.). T. 2. Moscow, Nauka, 1964.

Gorokhov V.G. “Philosophy of management in the Soviet Union in 60’s – 70’s (a restrospective analysis)” (“Filosofiya upravleniya v Sovetskom Soyuze v 60-e – 70-e gg. KhKh veka (retrospektivnyy analiz)”). Filosofiya upravleniya: problemy i strategii (Philosophy of management: problems and strategies). Moscow, 2010. Pp.254-299.

Gorokhov V.G. From classical radiolocation to radiolocational systemotechnics (Ot klassicheskoy radiolokatsii k radiolokatsionnoy sistemotekhnike (sotsial'nyy i metodologicheskiy analiz istorii stanovleniya i razvitiya sovremennoy nauchno-tekhnicheskoy distsipliny)). Issledovano v Rossii. 2009, no. 106, pp. 1372-1400. Available at:

Gorokhov V.G. Galileo Galilei’s technoscience (Tekhnonauka Galileo Galileya: razmyshleniya po povodu knigi Mateo Valeriani Galileo - inzhener (M. Valleriani. Galileo engineer. Dordrecht, Heidelberg, London, New York: Springer, 2010). Voprosy filosofii, 2013, no. 1, pp. 105-116.

Gorokhov V.G. Lessons of the reform of education in Russia in the end of XIX – beginning of XX centuries (Uroki reformy obrazovaniya v Rossii kontsa XIX – nachala XX stoletiy). Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii – Higher Education in Russia, 2010, no. 5.

Gorokhov V.G. Scientific engineering education: a convergence of Russian and German experience (Nauchnoe inzhenernoe obrazovanie: konvergentsiya rossiyskogo i germanskogo opyta). Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii – Higher Education in Russia. 2012, no. 11.

Gorokhov V.G. Tekhnicheskie nauki: istoriya i teoriya (istoriya nauki s filosofskoy tochki zreniya) (Technical sciences: history and theory (the history of science from a philosophical point of view). Moscow, Logos, 2012.

Mandel'shtam L.I. “Vvedenie” (“Introduction”). 50 let radio. Sbornik original'nykh statey i materialov (50 years of radio: a collection of original articles and materials). Moscow, Leningrad, 1948.

Mandelstam L., Papalexi N. Ferdinand Braun zum Gedächtnis. In: Die Naturwissenschaften, 1928, Heft 32. Available at:

Maxwell J.K. O deystviyakh na rasstoyanii (On the actions of the distance). Dzhems Klerk Maksvell. Stat'i i rechi (J.C.Maxwell: articles and speeches). Moscow, Nauka, 1968, pp. 18-19.

Pechenkin A.A. Leonid Isaakovich Mandel'shtam. Issledovanie, prepodavanie i ostal'naya zhizn' (Leonid Isaakovich Mandel'shtam: research, teaching and other life). Moscow, Logos, 2011.

Valleriani M. Metallurgy, Ballistics and Epistemic Instruments. The Nova scientia of Nicolò Tartaglia. A New Edition. English translation by Matteo Valleriani, Lindy Divarci and Anna Siebold. Berlin: Edition Open Access, 2013.

Full Text: